7
6387 5th Side Rd, Innisfil, ON L9S 3R7, Canada
Innisfil, Ontario L9S 3R7
+17054589191

Had the classic poutine. Fries here are really bad (for a place with fries in the name, what are they doing?) but the gravy was mid and the cheese was decent (curd-like) and the ratios were really good (nice amount of cheese), so it gets a 3/5.

Horrible!!! I was standing at Tim Hortons staring at New York fries but I couldn’t go there because they were closed. All I wanted was a poutine to help me through my latest breakup and I couldn’t get it. I am very disappointed and even more depressed then I was before. I am now standing in the rain over-indulging on chocolate glazed donuts and drowning my sorrows in double doubles.

We got a chili dog and a poutine today and had a good experience here. The worker should get a raise for being the only one working during a lunch rush.

If there’s no one else ordering when you’re there, don’t. Fries will be luke warm at best from a batch they made previously. They’ve changed their packaging from an overly stuffed paper cup to a less than full brown box. For the price you pay, seeing a half full container is completely disappointing. A medium fry and a small poutine cost us $12. And with the pandemic all toppings are hidden away and you hope the counter person listens to your request when you ask for a giant handful of vinegar or lots of Cajun spice on top... they didn’t.

I got butter chicken fries, the gravy was not even warm. I took the order back and asked them if they can give me warm gravy. The chesse on fries wasn’t melted as well. The guy said this is how we serve. They asked me if i want more gravy they can give me extra. People don’t complaint to get extra. People complaint when they don’t get service they expected.

Our hot dogs were cold , had a poutine that the fries were discussing fravy was cold and the cheese curds stayed solid. Very poor food never eating New York Fries or any of their food again

Figure out your hotdogs, this place never has any ready despite rotating staff a few times. 1 of the last 10 times coming through here they had them ready. It's the only location of nyf I've had this issue at this consistently.

Show Map

New York Fries ONroute Cookstown — Restaurant in Innisfil

We are glad to greet you!

New York Fries ONroute Cookstown

Restaurant at 6387 5th Side Rd, Innisfil, ON L9S 3R7, Canada. Here you will find detailed information about New York Fries ONroute Cookstown: address, phone, fax, opening hours, customer reviews, photos, directions and more.

Opening hours

  • Sunday
    11 AM–8 PM
  • Monday
    12–5 PM
  • Tuesday
    12–5 PM
  • Wednesday
    12–5 PM
  • Thursday
    11 AM–7 PM
  • Friday
    11 AM–7 PM
  • Saturday
    11 AM–8 PM

Rating

2
/
5
Based on 7 reviews

Contacts

Categories:
State:
Ontario
Address:
6387 5th Side Rd, Innisfil, ON L9S 3R7, Canada.
City:
Innisfil
Phone:
Postcode:
L9S 3R7

About New York Fries ONroute Cookstown

New York Fries ONroute Cookstown is a Canadian Restaurant based in Innisfil, Ontario. New York Fries ONroute Cookstown is located at 6387 5th Side Rd, Innisfil, ON L9S 3R7, Canada.


Please contact with New York Fries ONroute Cookstown using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find New York Fries ONroute Cookstown opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.

Are you the owner?
You can make a change to the page:
Edit this page

ALL reviews about New York Fries ONroute Cookstown

  • Sam Maier
    Added 2025.07.13
    Had the classic poutine. Fries here are really bad (for a place with fries in the name, what are they doing?) but the gravy was mid and the cheese was decent (curd-like) and the ratios were really good (nice amount of cheese), so it gets a 3/5.
  • By owner
    Added 2025.07.14
    Please send us an email at [email protected] with your reference #3427-0713-SM
  • Gary
    Added 2024.08.17
    Horrible!!! I was standing at Tim Hortons staring at New York fries but I couldn’t go there because they were closed. All I wanted was a poutine to help me through my latest breakup and I couldn’t get it. I am very disappointed and even more depressed then I was before. I am now standing in the rain over-indulging on chocolate glazed donuts and drowning my sorrows in double doubles.
  • Evelyn
    Added 2021.12.29
    We got a chili dog and a poutine today and had a good experience here. The worker should get a raise for being the only one working during a lunch rush.
  • By owner
    Added 2021.12.29
    Hello, we are happy to hear you had a good experience! Thank you for the feedback. We hope to see you again sometime soon!
  • Coryna U
    Added 2021.04.26
    If there’s no one else ordering when you’re there, don’t. Fries will be luke warm at best from a batch they made previously. They’ve changed their packaging from an overly stuffed paper cup to a less than full brown box. For the price you pay, seeing a half full container is completely disappointing. A medium fry and a small poutine cost us $12. And with the pandemic all toppings are hidden away and you hope the counter person listens to your request when you ask for a giant handful of vinegar or lots of Cajun spice on top... they didn’t.
  • Prabhjot kaur
    Added 2020.03.01
    I got butter chicken fries, the gravy was not even warm. I took the order back and asked them if they can give me warm gravy. The chesse on fries wasn’t melted as well. The guy said this is how we serve. They asked me if i want more gravy they can give me extra. People don’t complaint to get extra. People complaint when they don’t get service they expected.
  • Debbie Stuart
    Added 2019.04.03
    Our hot dogs were cold , had a poutine that the fries were discussing fravy was cold and the cheese curds stayed solid. Very poor food never eating New York Fries or any of their food again
  • Kevin Theiss
    Added 2019.01.12
    Figure out your hotdogs, this place never has any ready despite rotating staff a few times. 1 of the last 10 times coming through here they had them ready. It's the only location of nyf I've had this issue at this consistently.
Leave your own review about New York Fries ONroute Cookstown:
Add a review

You Might Also Consider

Toast Homestyle
Restaurant in Ontario
7 reviews
24 Queen St, Cookstown, ON L0L 1L0, Canada.
Swiss Chalet
Restaurant in Ontario
7 reviews
1466 Innisfil Beach Rd, Innisfil, ON L9S 4J1, Canada.
C.W. Coop's Innisfil
Restaurant in Ontario
7 reviews
808 Innisfil Beach Rd, Innisfil Beach, ON L9S 2C3, Canada.